Ethan buys an engagement ring for his girlfriend at the same time Gary buys a simple gift for his girlfriend, Rachel, at Tiffany's. When they leave the store, Gray gets hit by a car, and when Ethan helps him, they accidentally switch their presents. The next day, Ethan and his daughter visit the hospital to check on Gary's well-being. There, he meets Michelle, who is there to visit Gary. Later, when they each separately hand over their presents to their girlfriends, they discover the mix-up. Gary pretends like nothing happened and proposes to Michelle with the ring, but Ethan, who wants the ring back, seeks out Gary while also encountering Michelle in various situations.
Even though the plot might sound a bit convoluted, this turns out to be a very good romantic movie that isn't quite like all the others. It ends as it should, etc., but still feels better than most.
