Cara and her daughter Megan are hosting Cara's ex-husband, Megan's father, and his new girlfriend over Christmas. It's a slightly unusual and not entirely comfortable arrangement. Megan writes a letter to Santa asking for her mother to find a boyfriend by Christmas, and the letter blows away, ending up at the town bakery where it's photographed and goes viral. This is picked up by Chet at the local TV station, who tracks down Cara to do a report. The situation escalates as he encourages Cara to start dating some of the people who write to her after the report. Eventually, Cara agrees to this. However, finding someone suitable proves to be more challenging than expected.
Perhaps not flawless, but it still received a rating of 4. It holds up as an average romantic film, even though it has some flaws.