Lily and her three best friends run a gift-wrapping shop. She’s about to go on a date with one of the town’s most sought-after bachelors, Owen. Before that, however, she manages to squeeze in an interview with Sean, who wants to write an article about their gift-wrapping business. It turns out they attended the same university at the same time but never knew each other. The date with Owen goes so-so, but well enough to lead to a second date. Meanwhile, Sean has some follow-up questions regarding the article. Suddenly, Lily finds herself caught between two men, both intriguing in very different ways.
This is a movie in the Unwrapping Christmas series, featuring standalone parallel storylines. Quite fun to watch together. They've put together a good romantic story that works well, even if it's naturally rather predictable.